Fiber vs Copper Broadband
What Might Qualify as an Equivalent Replacement for a Copper Based Telephone Landline?
Introduction:
Retiring a copper telephone network is not simply a change of transmission medium. A migration can change where power is supplied, how calls are established, how connected equipment communicates, and which components must remain operational during an emergency. The objective is equivalence of required service outcomes—not replication of every characteristic of the old network. This article proposes a framework for evaluating those outcomes; it does not describe an existing regulatory certification.
The issue is becoming concrete for California customers. In its May 20, 2026 announcement, AT&T committed $19 billion through 2030 to fiber and wireless investment and described plans to discontinue specified copper-based services in parts of California on or after June 1, 2027. The company also committed to continued access to voice and 911 service. These are announced plans and commitments, not evidence of completed migration outcomes (more below).
The engineering question is more demanding than whether a replacement produces dial tone. A meaningful assessment should examine the functions customers depend on: conversational performance, emergency calling, power resilience, connected-device compatibility, and recovery after failure.
Separate the Access Connection From the Telephone Service:
“Fiber,” “wireless,” and “digital voice” describe different aspects of a communications system. A migration assessment should identify both the connection serving the premises and the voice service operating over it. Ofcom describes the UK’s digital-landline transition as a move to Voice over Internet Protocol, or VoIP. Its guidance also explains that customers do not necessarily need to purchase a high-speed broadband package to retain telephone service. The service requirement and the broadband product offered to a customer are therefore not interchangeable.
For evaluation purposes, three questions should remain separate:
-
Is the access connection operational?
-
Can the telephone service establish and receive calls?
-
Does the complete installation deliver the functions the customer requires?
An answer to the first question does not settle the other two. The proposed assessment should follow the entire service path, rather than treating the access technology as a proxy for telephone-service performance.
Power Resilience Requires a Complete Installation Test:
Traditional exchange-powered telephone service could keep a basic corded telephone working during a household power failure. Broadband-based voice introduces a different dependency: equipment at the customer’s premises needs electricity. Ofcom warns that digital landlines require a resilience solution if they are to remain usable during a power cut.
That distinction should not become a claim that copper service was immune to failure. It identifies a particular capability that a migration may need to preserve: telephone access when household mains power is unavailable.
The proposed acceptance procedure should identify every premises component required for calling and establish which backup arrangement powers each one. The test should then disconnect household mains power and verify the installed service—not merely inspect a battery indicator.
The resulting record should state:
-
Which equipment receives backup power.
-
Whether incoming and outgoing calls remain possible.
-
The tested standby duration and calling duty cycle.
-
The battery condition and replacement responsibility.
-
What happens when mains power returns.
A premises test also has a boundary: it cannot establish how long the provider’s external network will remain available during a regional outage. Installation-level results and provider-level resilience evidence should be documented separately.
Evaluate Conversation, Not Just Call Establishment:
The framework should distinguish successful call setup from an acceptable conversation.
A practical test program would evaluate incoming and outgoing calls under representative conditions, including simultaneous household broadband use where applicable. It should record call completion, audible interruptions, conversational delay, unexpected disconnections, and performance during relevant busy periods.
Rather than prescribing one universal numerical threshold, the migration plan should identify the applicable performance objectives and their basis. The acceptance record should make clear what was measured, under which conditions, and what constituted a passing result.
This approach avoids declaring one technology inherently superior. It asks whether the deployed service meets an explicit requirement.
Wireless Replacements Need Site-Specific Evidence:
AT&T’s California announcement identifies AT&T Phone – Advanced and AT&T Business Voice among its replacement offerings. The company states that these products provide battery backup and support existing telephones and various connected devices. Those statements should be presented as provider claims, not independent compatibility findings for every installation.about.att
The assessment should identify the product’s actual access arrangement rather than grouping every wireless-enabled voice product under one technical description.
For a wireless installation, the proposed checks include:
-
Reception at the equipment’s installed location.
-
Call completion and conversational performance at relevant busy periods.
-
Operation with household mains power disconnected.
-
Recovery after a loss of connectivity.
-
Successful operation of identified connected devices.
-
Any alternative communications path included in the service design.
A coverage statement and an installation acceptance result answer different questions. The proposed framework requires evidence about the installed service.
A Telephone Socket Does Not Establish Device Compatibility:
Some telephone connections support applications beyond conversation. Ofcom specifically advises customers to check equipment such as telecare devices and burglar alarms before switching to digital landlines.
The technical distinction is important: a signal that remains intelligible to a person may not be reproduced accurately enough for a machine. RFC 4733 explains that low-bit-rate speech codecs cannot be assumed to reproduce signaling tones reliably for automatic recognition. It defines mechanisms for transporting telephone events, including keypad digits, separately from ordinary encoded speech.
IETF RFC 4733 also discusses distinct approaches for fax, voice-band data, and modem communications, including T.38, V.152, and V.150.1. These mechanisms address different signal types; their existence is not a universal compatibility guarantee. Acceptance should therefore test the application’s complete transaction. For an alarm, that would mean verifying that the event reaches the monitoring center, identifies the correct account or location, and receives the expected acknowledgment. If migration requires replacing the connected device, the replacement should be evaluated as a new end-to-end system, including fault reporting and recovery—not simply described as preservation of the old telephone interface.
Emergency Access Needs Its Own Acceptance Plan:
The proposed framework should treat emergency access as a separate service requirement, with documented arrangements for:
-
Call origination and routing.
-
Service-location information.
-
Callback capability.
-
Operation during a premises power failure.
-
Recovery after equipment restart or access failure.
Verification should use provider-supported procedures and an agreed process with the relevant emergency organization. The framework does not call for unsolicited test calls to emergency numbers.
Any live emergency-calling validation must follow an agreed procedure with the provider and relevant emergency organization—not an unsolicited test call.
Network-side resilience also deserves attention. U.S. rules for covered 911 service providers address physical diversity, operational integrity, and monitoring. These obligations concern specified emergency-network facilities; they should not be confused with a blanket guarantee that every residential connection survives a prolonged outage. Evidence should also be matched to its scope. A successful installation test does not demonstrate regional emergency-network availability, just as a provider’s network-resilience statement does not demonstrate that a particular household has functioning backup power.
Fiber-based voice: access capacity is not the same as voice assurance:
ITU-T Recommendation G.9807.1 specifies XGS-PON, a 10-Gigabit-capable symmetric passive optical network. It is an access-network specification—not a certification that a particular retail telephone service reproduces every function of an analog line.
The voice service has additional layers. IETF RFC 3261 defines the Session Initiation Protocol, or SIP, used to establish, modify, and terminate sessions. Voice quality also depends on the media path and signal processing, not merely successful session establishment.rfc-editor+1
This creates an important distinction between three tests:
-
The access connection is operational.
-
A telephone call can be established.
-
The resulting conversation meets an acceptable quality and reliability target.
ITU-T G.114 addresses the effect of one-way transmission delay. G.107’s E-model provides a planning framework for considering transmission impairments, including delay and codec-related effects. ITU technical guidance also explains the jitter-buffer trade-off: buffering can accommodate variations in packet arrival time, but adds delay.itu+1
A proposed migration test should therefore measure conversational performance under realistic simultaneous broadband use—not only with an otherwise idle connection. The relevant evidence would include delay, packet loss, conversational interruptions, call completion, and performance at busy periods.
The objective is not to declare IP voice inherently inferior or superior. It is to establish whether the deployed service meets its stated performance objectives.
Fixed wireless (FWA): validate the installation, not just the coverage map:
Fixed-wireless voice is another migration option. AT&T’s May 2026 California announcement describes a transition toward fiber and wireless services, including AT&T Phone – Advanced and AT&T Business Voice. The company states that these products include battery backup and support existing telephones and various connected devices. Those are provider claims, not independent compatibility results for every installation.
For a fixed-wireless replacement, a useful acceptance procedure would examine:
-
Reception at the actual installed equipment location.
-
Call completion and audio quality during busy periods.
-
Battery operation with household electricity disconnected.
-
Recovery after loss of radio connectivity.
-
The behavior of connected alarms and monitoring equipment.
-
Whether an alternative communication path is available when the primary service fails.
These are proposed engineering checks, not assertions that a particular wireless product fails them.
“Wireless coverage exists” and “this installation provides an adequate replacement” are different propositions. The second requires site-specific evidence.
Legacy devices: intelligible speech does not prove compatibility:
An analog telephone line may carry more than conversation. Ofcom specifically warns customers to check equipment such as telecare devices and burglar alarms before migration.
The technical difficulty is that a signal understandable to a person is not necessarily reproduced accurately enough for a machine.
RFC 4733 explains why separate transport of telephone events is useful: low-bit-rate speech codecs cannot be assumed to reproduce signaling tones accurately enough for automatic recognition. The RFC defines RTP payload formats for DTMF digits and other telephone events and tones.
Relevant standards address different aspects of the problem:
| Standard | Relevance to migration |
|---|---|
| IETF RFC 4733 | Transport of DTMF digits and other telephone events and tones in RTP. |
| ITU-T T.38 | Specialized transport for Group 3 fax over IP networks. |
| ITU-T V.152 | Procedures for supporting voice-band data over IP networks. |
| ITU-T V.150.1 | Procedures for modem relay across IP networks. |
These mechanisms are distinct; they are not a universal compatibility guarantee. RFC 4733 identifies T.38, V.152, and V.150.1 as alternative approaches for particular signal types. ITU guidance further explains that voice-band data may require changes such as disabling voice-activity detection and comfort-noise generation during data transfer.itu+1
Consequently, an adapter with a familiar telephone socket should not be treated as proof that every attached application will work.
A stronger migration procedure would test the complete transaction: an alarm reaches its monitoring center, receives the expected acknowledgment, and reports the correct account or location. Where replacement equipment is needed, the installation should be evaluated as a new end-to-end system rather than as transparent preservation of the old interface.
Backup-power requirements: distinguish a minimum from a guarantee:
Ofcom’s guidance calls for a solution enabling access to emergency organizations for at least one hour during a premises power cut. Providers should offer the solution free to customers dependent on their landline for emergency calling. Ofcom’s consumer guidance recognizes that a mobile solution is appropriate only where there is usable mobile coverage.
The United States requires particular care when discussing historical rules. The retrieved text of 47 CFR §9.20 describes requirements to offer eight-hour and twenty-four-hour standby backup options for covered residential services that are not line-powered. However, that same text contains an explicit September 1, 2025 sunset provision. It should not be cited without qualification as an ongoing October 2026 requirement. Even as an engineering benchmark, standby duration is not identical to continuous talk time, network availability, or guaranteed operation throughout a regional emergency. A replacement-service specification should state the assumed duty cycle, battery condition, maintenance responsibility, and equipment included in the backup arrangement.
Image Generated by Perplexity.ai which was also used for research contained in this article.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
Industry activity makes this a high priority issue:
AT&T’s May 20, 2026 California announcement commits $19 billion through 2030 to fiber and wireless investment. It also describes plans to discontinue specified copper-based services in parts of California on or after June 1, 2027, while committing that customers will retain access to voice and 911 service.
“Californians depend on and expect fast, reliable connectivity every day and AT&T is committed to delivering it,” said Susan Santana, state president of AT&T California. “With recent, forward-looking federal network modernization policies, we’re able to make our largest-ever California investment commitment ($19 billion) as we transition away from copper networks. As the largest fiber builder in the state, this expands future-ready fiber and wireless services at affordable prices and modernizes copper networks. By investing in newer, more reliable technology, we can deliver better service, reach more customers, improve our communities, and support California’s economy for years to come.”
–>These are AT&T announced plans and commitments, not completed migration outcomes.
In the UK, Ofcom’s digital-landline guidance places particular emphasis on customers dependent on telephone service and on equipment connected to the line. The transition is therefore not solely an infrastructure replacement program; it also requires identifying customer needs and resolving application-level dependencies.ofcom+1
The common challenge is translating broad continuity commitments into installation-level evidence.
A proposed replacement-service acceptance framework:
No single standard cited above defines a universal substitute for every telephone landline. A practical assessment could instead use a documented service profile:
| Dimension | Proposed acceptance evidence |
|---|---|
| Basic calling | Successful incoming and outgoing calls, ringing, required calling features, and number retention where applicable. |
| Conversational performance | Results against stated objectives under representative operating conditions. |
| Premises power resilience | Demonstrated operation of all necessary equipment for an agreed duration and calling duty cycle. |
| Emergency access | Documented verification of routing, location handling, and callback arrangements through an approved procedure. |
| Connected applications | Successful end-to-end transactions for identified alarms, monitoring systems, fax devices, or other required equipment. |
| Recovery and restoration | Observed restart and reconnection behavior, plus documented fault-reporting and repair arrangements. |
| Costs and responsibilities | Clear allocation of equipment, battery replacement, maintenance, compatibility remediation, and support obligations. |
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-47/chapter-I/subchapter-A/part-9/subpart-H/section-9.20
https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-47/chapter-I/subchapter-A/part-9/subpart-H
https://www.itu.int/dms_pubrec/itu-t/rec/g/T-REC-G.9807.1-202010-S!Amd2!TOC-HTM-E.htm
https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc4733/
https://about.att.com/story/2026/att-makes-ca-commitment.html
AT&T’s Fiber Expansion Strengthens Its Converged Wireless and Home Broadband Strategy
S&P Global Market Intelligence Surveys: Fiber Deployments in U.S. and Europe + AI Infrastructure Causes Market Shift
T-Mobile expands FTTH footprint via 50-50 JVs with Oak Hill Capital and Wren House
2026 Fiber Connect Keynote: “The Future of Fiber Optics: AI and the Quantum”
More KPN customers use fiber vs copper for broadband services in Nederlands
U.S. fiber rollouts now pass ~52% of homes and businesses but are still far behind HFC
Automating Fiber Testing in the Last Mile: An Experiment from the Field
By Said Yakhyoev with Sridhar Talari & Ajay Thakur
The December 23, 2025 IEEE ComSoc Tech Blog post on AI-driven data center buildouts [1.] highlights the urgent need to scale optical fiber and related equipment[1]. While much of the industry focus is on manufacturing capacity and high-density components inside data centers, a different bottleneck is emerging downstream— a sprawling last-mile network that demands testing, activation, and long-term maintenance. The AI-driven fiber demand coincided with the historic federal broadband programs to bring fiber to the premises for millions of customers[2]. This not only adds near-term pressure on fiber supply chains, but also creates a longer-term operational challenge: efficiently servicing hundreds of thousands of new fiber endpoints in the field.
As standard-setting bodies and vendors are introducing optimized products and automation inside data centers, similar future-proofing is needed in the last-mile outside plant. This post presents an example of such innovation from a field perspective, based on hands-on experimentation with a robotic tool designed to automate fiber testing inside existing Fiber Distribution Hubs (FDHs).
While central office copper terminating DSLAMs—and Optical Line Terminals (OLTs) in Passive Optical Networks (PONs)—aggregate subscribers and automate testing and provisioning, FDHs function as passive patch panels[3] that deliberately omit electronics to reduce cost. Between an OLT and the subscriber, the passive distribution network remains fixed. As a result, accessing individual ports at a local FDH—and anything downstream of it—remains a manual process. In active networks, DSLAMs and OLTs can electronically manage thousands of subscribers efficiently, but during construction this manual access is a bottleneck. There are likely tens of thousands of FDHs deployed nationwide.
Consider this problem from a technician’s perspective: suburban and urban Fiber to the Home (FTTH) networks are often deployed using a hub-and-spoke architecture centered around FDHs. These cabinets carry between 144 and 432 ports serving customers in a neighborhood, and each line must be tested bidirectionally[4]. In practice, this typically requires two technicians: one stationed at the FDH to move the test equipment between ports, and another at the customer location or terminal.
Testing becomes difficult during inclement weather. Counterintuitively, the technician stationed at the hub—often standing still for long periods—is more exposed than technicians moving between poles in vehicles. In addition to discomfort, there is a real economic penalty: either a skilled technician is tied up performing repetitive port switching, or an additional helper must be assigned. Above all, dependence on both favorable weather and helper availability makes testing schedules unpredictable and slows network completion.
To mitigate this bottleneck, we developed and tested Machine2 (M2)—a compact, gantry-style robotic tool that remotely connects an optical test probe inside an FDH, allowing a single technician to perform bidirectional testing independently.
M2 was designed to retrofit into a commonly deployed 288-port Clearfield FDH used in rural and small-town networks. The available space in front of the patch panel—approximately 9.5 × 28 × 4 inches—constrained the design to a flat Cartesian mechanism capable of navigating between ports and inserting a standard SC connector. Despite the simple design, integrating M2 into an unmodified FDH in the field proved more challenging than expected. Several real-world constraints shaped the redesign.
![]() |
![]() |
| FDH cabinet. Space to fit an automated switch | M2 installed for dry-run testing |
Space and geometry constraints: The patch panel occupies roughly 80% of the available volume, leaving only a narrow strip for motors, electronics, and cable routing. This forced compromises in pulley placement, leadscrew length, and motor orientation, limiting motion and requiring multiple iterations. The same constraints also limited battery size, making energy efficiency a primary design concern.
Port aiming: The patch panel is composed of cassettes with loosely constrained SC connectors. Small variations in connector position led to unreliable insertions. After repeated attempts, small misalignments accumulated, rendering the system ineffective without corrective feedback.
Communications reliability: A specialized cellular modem intended for IoT applications performed poorly for command-and-control. Message latency ranged from 1.5 seconds to over 12 seconds – and in some cases minutes – making real-time control impractical. In rural areas of Connecticut and Vermont, cellular coverage was also inconsistent or absent. Thus, the effort was abandoned between 2022 and 2024.
When the project resumed, an unexpected solution emerged. A low-cost consumer mobile hotspot proved more reliable than the specialized modem when cellular signal was available, providing predictable latency and stable Wi-Fi connectivity inside the FDH—even with the all-metal cabinet door closed and locked.
To further reduce latency, we explored using the fiber under test itself as a communication channel, a kind of temporary orderwire. When a two-piece Optical Loss Test Set (OLTS) is connected across an intact fiber, the devices indicate link readiness via an LED. By tapping this status signal, M2 can infer when a technician at the far end disconnects the meter and automatically connects to the next port. While this cue-based mode is limited, it enables near-zero-latency coordination and rapid testing of multiple ports without spoken or typed commands, which proved effective for common field workflows.
A second breakthrough came from addressing port aiming with vision. Standard computer-vision techniques such as edge detection were sufficient to micro-adjust the probe position at individual ports. To detect and avoid dust caps, M2 also uses a lightweight edge-ML[5] model trained to recognize caps under varying illumination. Using only 30 positive and 30 negative training images, the model correctly detected caps in over 80% of cases.
In our experience, lightweight vision models proved sufficient for practical field tasks, suggesting that accessibility—not sophistication—may drive adoption of automation in outside-plant environments.
What building M2 revealed:
- Overcoming communications issues led to an intriguing idea: optical background communication, where modulated laser light subtly changes ambient illumination inside the FDH that a camera can detect and extract instructions.
- M2 also proved useful beyond testing. For example, in a verify-as-you-splice workflow, M2 can lase a specific fiber as confirmation before splicing. Interactive port illumination and detection allow a single technician to troubleshoot complex situations.
The comparison below is illustrative and reflects observed workflows rather than controlled benchmarking.
Illustrative comparison of testing workflows in our experience
| Human helper (remote) | M2 | |
| Connect next port | 1–1.5 s | 2.5–4 s |
| Connect random / distant port | 8–24 s | ~11–30 s |
| Ease of deployment | Requires flat ground, fair weather, ground-level FDH | ~15 min setup; requires software familiarity |
| Functionality | Highly adaptable | Limited to 2–3 functions |
| Economics | Inefficient for small networks | Well-suited for small and medium networks |
| Independence factor | Low; requires two people | High; largely weather-independent |
| Best use | Variable builds, high adaptability | Repetitive builds, independent workflows |
Early insights for OSP vendors and standards
Building M2 revealed two broader lessons relevant to operators and vendors. First, there are now practical opportunities for automation to enter outside-plant workflows following developments in the power industry and datacenters[6]. Second, infrastructure design choices can facilitate this transition.
More spacious or reconfigurable FDH cabinets would simplify retrofitting active devices. Standardized attachment points on cabinets, terminals and pluggable components would allow mechanized or automated fiber management, reducing the risk of damage in dense installations.
Fiducial marks are among the lowest-cost adaptations. QR marks conveying dimensions and part architecture would help machines determine part orientation and position easily. Although these are common in the industry, it may be time to adopt them more broadly in telecom infrastructure maintenance.
Aerial terminals may benefit the most from machine-friendly design. Standardized port spacing and swing-out or hinged caps would significantly simplify autonomous or remotely assisted connections. Such cooperative interfaces could enable standoff connections without requiring a technician to climb a pole, improving safety and reducing access costs. Retrofitting aerial infrastructure to make it robot-friendly has been recommended[7] by the power industry and is also needed in the broadband utilities.
Conclusion
A growing gap is emerging between rapidly evolving data-center infrastructure and the more traditional telecom networks downstream. As fiber density increases, testing, activation, and maintenance of last-mile networks are likely to become bottlenecks. One way ISPs and vendors can future-proof outside-plant infrastructure is by proactively incorporating automation- and robot-friendly design features. M2 is one practical example that helps inform how such transitions might begin.
Short video clip from our early field trial in Massachusetts:
https://youtube.com/shorts/MiDoQd_S6Kw
References:
[1] IEEE ComSoc Technology blog post, Dec 23 2025, How will fiber and equipment vendors meet the increased demand for fiber optics in 2026 due to AI data center buildouts? ↩
[2] U.S. Dept. of Commerce Office of Inspector General, “NTIA Broadband Programs: Semiannual Status Report,” Washington, DC, USA, Rep. no. OIG-25-031-I, Sept. 24, 2025. ↩
[3] for an overview of an FTTH architecture see: Fiber Optic Association (FOA), FTTH Network Design Considerations and Fiber Optic Association (FOA), FTTH and PON Applications ↩
[4] Corning Optical Communications, “Corning Recommended Fiber Optic Test Guidelines,” Hickory, NC, USA, Application Engineering Note LAN-1561-AEN, Feb. 2020. ↩
[5] Refer to tools available for easy to use edge computing by Edge Impulse. ↩
[6] See state of the art indoor optical switches like ROME from NTT-AT and G5 from Telescent. ↩
[7] Andrew Phillips, “Autonomous overhead transmission line inspection robot (TI) development and demonstration,” IEEE PES General Meeting, 2014. ↩
About the Author:
Said Yakhyoev is a fiber optic technician with LightStep LLC in Colorado and a developer of the experimental Machine2 (M2) platform for automating fiber testing in outside-plant networks.
The author acknowledges the use of AI-assisted tools for language refinement and formatting.
Frontier Communications fiber build-out boom continues: record number of fiber subscribers added in the 1st quarter of 2023
Frontier Communications added record number of fiber broadband customers in the 1st quarter of 2023. The fiber facility based network operator added 87,000 fiber subscribers (including 83,000 residential subs) in the first quarter of 2023, up from +54,000 in the year-ago quarter. Those results beat the 76,000 residential fiber subs Frontier was expected to add in the period. Frontier ended the quarter with 1.76 million fiber customers: 1.65 million residential subscribers and 110,000 business customers.
“We delivered another strong quarter and reached a critical milestone in our transformation. Thanks to our team’s consistent operational performance, we achieved EBITDA growth for the first time in five years,” said Nick Jeffery, President and Chief Executive Officer of Frontier.
“We are creating an internet company that people love. Over the last two years, we have rallied around our purpose of Building Gigabit America, invested in fiber, enhanced our product, put the customer at the center of everything we do and made it easier to do business with us. We are quickly becoming an agile, digital infrastructure company, and I’m confident we will return to growth this year.”

Frontier said it built fiber to an additional 339,000 locations in Q1 2023, up 60% from the 211,000 it built in the year-ago period. Frontier’s Q1 buildout was better than the 300,000 locations expected by the analysts at New Street Research. Frontier ended the quarter with 5.5 million fiber passings and 15.4 million total passings.
First-Quarter 2023 Consolidated Financial Results:
• Revenue of $1.44 billion decreased 0.5% from the first quarter of 2022 as growth in consumer, business and wholesale fiber was more than offset by declines in legacy copper
• Operating income was $143 million and net income was $3 million
• Adjusted EBITDA of $519 million increased 2.0% over the first quarter of 2022 as revenue declines were more than offset by lower content, selling, general and administrative expenses, and cost-saving initiatives
• Adjusted EBITDA margin of 36.0% increased from 35.2% in the first quarter of 2022
• Capital expenditures of $1.15 billion increased from $0.45 billion in the first quarter of 2022 as fiber expansion initiatives accelerated First-Quarter 2023
Consumer Results:
• Consumer revenue of $761 million decreased 1.9% from the first quarter of 2022 as strong growth in fiber broadband was more than offset by declines in legacy copper broadband and voice
• Consumer fiber revenue of $448 million increased 10.1% over the first quarter of 2022 as growth in consumer broadband, voice, and other more than offset declines in video
• Consumer fiber broadband revenue of $298 million increased 17.3% over the first quarter of 2022 driven by growth in fiber broadband customers
• Consumer fiber broadband customer net additions of 84,000 resulted in consumer fiber broadband customer growth of 19.5% from the first quarter of 2022
• Consumer fiber broadband customer churn of 1.20% was roughly flat with churn of 1.19% in the first quarter of 2022
• Consumer fiber broadband ARPU of $61.44 decreased 1.1% from the first quarter of 2022 driven primarily by the autopay and gift-card incentives introduced in the third quarter of 2021 First-Quarter 2023
Business and Wholesale Results:
• Business and wholesale revenue of $657 million decreased 1.4% from the first quarter of 2022 as growth in fiber was more than offset by declines in copper
• Business and wholesale fiber revenue of $281 million increased 6.0% over the first quarter of 2022 as growth in business was partly offset by modest declines in wholesale
• Business fiber broadband customer churn of 1.45% increased from 1.24% in the first quarter of 2022
• Business fiber broadband ARPU of $104.38 decreased 1.2% from the first quarter of 2022
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..
While Frontier’s fiber growth engine continues to hum along, the company is dealing with higher costs related to its fiber initiative. The company raised its 2023 capex guidance to a range of $3 billion to $3.2 billion, up from an original outlook of $2.8 billion.
Frontier blamed the increase on a couple of factors – a decision to build inventory opportunistically where it saw supply chains ease a bit in the quarter and higher build costs as it scales its build into new geographies. Frontier is also seeing higher labor costs being driven by general inflation and higher rates as some of its multi-year labor contracts come up for renewal.
The anticipated increase in capex this year concerned investors. Frontier shares were down $2.33 (-10.94%) to $19.13 each in Friday morning trading.
Overall, Frontier expects fiber build costs in 2023 to be in the range of $1,000 to $1,100. But it’s confident that total project build costs will remain at about $1,000 per location as it mixes in lower-cost locations in some new-build states and benefits from aerial builds and an increased focus on multiple dwelling units (MDUs), Frontier CFO Scott Beasley said on Friday’s earnings call.
The current capex picture isn’t expected to impact Frontier’s overall fiber buildout/upgrade plan. “We’re confident that the 10 million locations is still attractive to build out,” Beasley said. Frontier is also continuing to explore an additional 1 million to 2 million additional fiber passings beyond the original 10 million target.
Frontier says it’s too early to tell how this year’s cost headwinds might impact future opportunities coming by way of the $42.5 billion Broadband Equity, Access and Deployment (BEAD) program. New Street Research estimates that there are 1.2 million BEAD-eligible locations in Frontier’s footprint. New Street Research expects ARPU pressure at Frontier to ease in the second quarter of the year and return to growth in the third quarter.
Frontier recently initiated several consumer pricing changes for value-added services that were previously free. Whole-home Wi-Fi, for example, now costs $10 per month, its Home Shield Elite product is now $6 per month extra and the company is now charging $50 for professional installs. Those actions are driving new fiber customer monthly ARPU to a range of $65 to $70, the company said.
Frontier is also speeding up its original cost savings target to $500 million by the end of 2024. Its prior target was $400 million by the end of 2024. Frontier is approaching that target through a range of streamlining and simplification initiatives, including improved field operations, self-service capabilities, the consolidation of call centers and an ongoing reduction in copper infrastructure.
Frontier’s guidance for the full year 2023:
• Adjusted EBITDA of $2.11 – $2.16 billion, unchanged from prior guidance
• Fiber build of 1.3 million new locations, unchanged from prior guidance
• Cash capital expenditures of $3.00 – $3.20 billion, an increase from prior guidance of $2.80 billion, reflecting higher inventory levels and fiber build costs
• Cash taxes of approximately $20 million, unchanged from prior guidance
• Net cash interest payments of approximately $655 million, an increase from prior guidance of $630 million, reflecting the $750 million of debt raised in March 2023
• Pension and OPEB expense of approximately $50 million (net of capitalization), unchanged from prior guidance
• Cash pension and OPEB contributions of approximately $125 million, unchanged from prior guidance
References:
Fiber builds propels Frontier Communication’s record 4th Quarter; unveils Fiber Innovation Labs
AT&T to use Frontier’s fiber infrastructure for 4G/5G backhaul in 25 states
Frontier Communications offers first network-wide symmetrical 5 Gig fiber internet service
Frontier Communications adds record fiber broadband customers in Q4 2022
Frontier’s Big Fiber Build-Out Continued in Q3-2022 with 351,000 fiber optic premises added
Frontier Communications sets another fiber buildout record; raises FTTP buildout target for 2022
“Fiber is the future” at Frontier, which added a record 54K fiber broadband customers in 1Q-2022
Frontier’s FTTP to reach 10M locations by 2025; +192,000 FTTP passings in 4Q-2021
Frontier Communications reports added 45,000 fiber broadband subscribers in 4Q-2021 – best in 5 years!
More KPN customers use fiber vs copper for broadband services in Nederlands
Dutch network operator KPN announced a new milestone on its fixed network: more customers are using fiber services than the old copper infrastructure for the first time. The disclosure was made in an internal announcement obtained by Telecompaper. KPN is seeing a steady increase in fiber orders in its consumer/residential market. The company said around 65% of orders are fiber and 35% for services on copper lines (DSL or POTs).
According to the Q1 Dutch Consumer Broadband report [1.], KPN had roughly the same number of residential DSL and fiber subscribers at the end of March, with just over 1.3 million lines each. While it has been adding fiber optic subscribers steadily each quarter, DSL losses remain slightly greater when including its second brand. The total consumer fixed broadband base has been flat (0% growth) over the past year.
Note 1. This Telecompaper report analyses developments in the first quarter of 2022 in the Dutch market for broadband internet access, focusing on consumer connections. The report further includes data on developments, fixed market revenues and broadband revenues. The findings are compared with results from previous periods. The analysis is based on Telecompaper’s continuous research into the development of the Dutch broadband communication services market. The focus is on cable network operators (Ziggo, Delta, Caiway), DSL providers (KPN, T-Mobile, Tele2, Online.nl, Budget Thuis) and FTTH providers (including KPN, T-Mobile, Caiway, Delta, Tele2, Online.nl, Budget Thuis).
…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..
Babak Fouladi, KPN’s Chief Technology & Digital Officer and member of the Board of Management, spoke at the Telecom Insights 2022 conference in May. He said:
“Telecom networks are essential and vital, and we do not only literally ensure that the world remains connected to everything and everyone. Our networks also support massive digitization, essential in crisis situations since online access is often the only door to the outside world and contact with others. Our networks enable people to work from home, study online or continue doing business. In addition, the digital infrastructure contributes to the global economy and to keeping healthcare and education affordable. And our infrastructure makes a structural contribution to reducing CO2 emissions, the use of fossil fuels and cleaner air. Digitization is more and more important as accelerator for sustainability.”
He concluded his speech with an appeal to the Dutch telecom sector: “Let’s make the Netherlands the best connected country in the world! Let’s make it happen, together.”

References:
https://www.overons.kpn/nieuws/en/lets-make-the-netherlands-the-best-connected-country-in-the-world/
57% of European homes can now get FTTH/B internet access; >50% growth forecast over next 5 years
Europe has reached 200 million (M) homes that are now able to access FTTH/B services. That number is forecast to grow over 50 percent in the next five years, to more than 300 million homes passed, according to the latest research commissioned by the FTTH Council Europe. The new figures were released at its annual conference in Vienna, along with fiber subscriber numbers and research intro rural coverage.
The latest research by Idate for the council shows nearly 198.4 million homes were passed by FTTH or FTTB as of September 2021, up from 176.3 million a year earlier. The annual expansion was led by France (+4.3 M), the UK (+3.4 M), Germany (+2.4 M) and Italy (+1.5 M), all countries with a strong copper network footprint that previously held back fiber optic deployments.
The figures cover 39 countries across Europe and equal 57 percent of total households in the area, up by 4.5 percent points from a year earlier. In the 27 EU countries plus the UK, the coverage reached 48.5 percent of homes, up by 4.6 percent over the 12 months.
The number of subscribers on the fiber networks reached 96 million. The fastest growing markets in terms of new subscribers were France (+3.8 M), Spain (+1.2 M), Romania (+1 M), Italy (+820 K) and the UK (+765K). In total, 48.5 percent of households able to receive fibre services actually subscribed to the services, an increase of 3.6 percent in the network penetration rate. In the EU plus UK, take-up was at 52.4 percent, up 5.6 percent year-on-year.

Alternative operators still account for the majority of the FTTH/N coverage (57%), with incumbent operators taking 39 percent and 4 percent built by municipalities and utilities. Overall, there is a strong acceleration in fiber deployment, with a firm commitment to cover both urban and rural areas, the researchers said.
Idate also updated its five-year forecast for the FTTH/B market. It expects 199 million homes passed in 2027 in the EU+UK region and 309 million in the wider EU 39 region. Over the same period, the number of subscribers is expected to reach respectively 124 million and 190 million, equal to network penetration of over 62 percent in the EU and UK and more than 61 percent in the EU 39.

Further research shows that only 30 percent of rural inhabitants could enjoy fibre network access as of September 2021. Rural FTTH/B coverage is highest in Denmark (76%), Latvia (74%), Spain (66%), Romania (62%) and Luxembourg (55%). The report emphasized that immediate action should be oriented towards the rural regions, with increased public support through subsidies and partnerships to cover every European premise with high-speed broadband.

At the conference, the FTTH Council also announced several awards for contributions to the industry’s progress. UK wholesale operator CityFibre received the operator award; Jacek Wisniewski, CEO of Polish operator Nexera received the individual award; and Eurofiber CEO Alex Goldblum was winner of the Charles Kao award, named after the eponymous scientist who won a Nobel prize for physics for his research into fiber-optic communications.
References:
https://www.fibre-systems.com/news/europe-track-meet-connectivity-targets-rural-areas-gaining-focus
Swisscom achieves 50 Gbps on a fixed PON connection – a world first!
Swisscom has achieved transmission speeds of 50 Gbps in a real PON (Passive Optical Network) environment test – a world first, according to the company. Swisscom has upgraded existing OLT (Optical Line Termination) hardware with a 50 Gbps PON Line Card prototype to reach a download speed of 50 Gbps and an upload speed of 25 Gbps on a fixed network.
The PON technology can be ready to market and deployed in around two years, according to Swisscom. It can be an option for business customers initially. Progressive network virtualization will enable companies to use the bandwidth they need on a flexible basis in line with their requirements.
The 10 Gbps service is expected to be sufficient for the residential mass market for several years yet, the company said. The 50 Gbps option allows for flexible deployment using existing fibre-optic infrastructure.
Markus Reber, Head of Swisscom Networks, said: “There is no question that the bandwidth need will continue to increase over the coming years. That’s why, here at Swisscom, we are already considering how our technology needs to develop to ensure that Switzerland continues to be ready to take advantage of the latest digital services with the best possible experience in the future. The results of testing based on PON technology and architecture clearly demonstrate that we have some powerful options available.”
“In my opinion, PON with 50 Gbit/s will be an option for the business customer market initially. Progressive network virtualisation will enable companies to use the bandwidth they need on a flexible basis in line with their requirements, for instance. In contrast, the 10 Gbit/s already available in the residential mass market should be more than enough for several years to come. However, the 50 Gbit/s option offers even more opportunities, as it allows the existing fibre optic infrastructure to be deployed in a more versatile way. As an example, the technology will soon facilitate access to mobile communication masts, particularly for 5G, as the same network can be used as the one already built to connect households. With a transmission speed of 50 Gbit/s, there is ample bandwidth available.”
The technology also will support fiber optic access to mobile communication masts, particularly for 5G, since the same network can be used as the one already built to connect households.
Swisscom says that “over the coming years, the development of digital applications will result in a similar growth in bandwidth need as seen in recent years, when it increased more than tenfold within a decade. Swisscom is therefore investing in network expansion on an ongoing basis, deploying the latest innovative technologies to do so and safeguarding Switzerland’s high degree of digital competitiveness.”
…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..
In April 2020, market research powerhouse Omdia (owned by Informa) forecast that In the 2018-2025 timeframe, the PON market will see a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 4.3% to be worth $8.4 billion by 2025. “This market remains in an upswing as operators continue to expand and upgrade their fiber-based access networks for both residential and non-residential subscribers and applications,” states the Omdia team in their report (published prior to the global impact of COVID-19, it should be noted).

Omdia: PON and xDSL/Gfast equipment market by major segment, 2017–2025
Growth in the PON market will be driven by increasing demand for next-generation PON equipment, including 10G GPON, 10G EPON, NG-PON2 and 25G/50G PON, according to Omdia: By 2021, most GPON OLT (optical line terminal) shipments are expected to be 10G.
Omdia expects demand for NG-PON2 equipment (which is expensive because it includes tunable lasers) is expected to be limited, with significant deployments anticipated only by one major operator, Verizon.
In Western Europe, PON investments are only just starting: That market is set for a CAGR of 16.5% to be worth $1.6 billion in 2025.
…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
References:
https://www.swisscom.ch/en/about/news/2020/10/08-weltpremiere.html
https://www.telecompaper.com/news/swisscom-reaches-50-gbps-in-real-network-environment–1357116
http://www.broadbandworldnews.com/document.asp?doc_id=758638
AT&T ends DSL sales while CWA criticizes AT&T’s broadband deployments
AT&T: DSL is Dead:
According to a message board post on DSL Reports, AT&T notified customers on billing statements in August that effective Oct. 1 it would no longer accept new orders for its copper-based DSL service. The notice also said that existing DSL subs will no longer be able to make speed changes to their respective DSL service.
The message board author wrote:
“On my August AT&T statement, traditional DSL is officially grandfathered effective October 1st. No new orders (moves, installs, speed change, etc.). Hopefully they will still allow promos….”
That’s no surprise to this author. AT&T’s DSL subscriber base has been eroding steadily – losing almost 350,000 subs over the past couple of years. In Q2 2020, AT&T shed 23,000 DSL subs, ending the period with just 463,000.
“We are focused on enhancing our network with more advanced, higher speed technologies like fiber and wireless, which consumers are demanding,” AT&T said in a statement. “We’re beginning to phase out outdated services like DSL and new orders for the service will no longer be supported after October 1. Current DSL customers will be able to continue their existing service or where possible upgrade to our 100% fiber network.”
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
AT&T Fiber Update:
AT&T also announced three new price points for its AT&T Fiber tiers and said that all new and existing AT&T Fiber Internet 100, Internet 300 and Internet 1000 subscribers would enjoy unlimited data without additional charges. AT&T Fiber started offering the new deals as a standalone product with no annual contracts for new customers on Sunday.
As of Q2-2020, AT&T had 4.3 million AT&T Fiber customers with nearly two million of them on 1-gigabit speeds. Overall, AT&T has about 15.3 million broadband subscribers while Charter has 28 million and Comcast has over 29 million.
AT&T’s fiber tier announcement comes after AT&T CEO John Stankey told a Goldman Sachs investor conference in September that “priority number one” is investing in fiber for 5G and FTTP services.
The new prices are also an indication that AT&T intends to ramp up its drive on FTTP sales in the wake of a recent study showing that many of AT&T’s new subs were coming from existing customers upgrading to fiber rather than from gaining market share from cable Internet operators (MSOs).
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
CWA Calls Out AT&T’s broadband efforts:
Coincidently today, the Communications Workers of America (CWA) criticized AT&T’s lack of fiber deployments. The report, co-authored with the National Inclusion Alliance (NDIA) stated:
AT&T is making the digital divide worse and failing its customers and workers by not investing in crucial buildout of fiber-optic infrastructure that is the standard for broadband networks worldwide. The company’s recent job cuts — more than 40,000 since 2018 — are devastating communities and hobbling the company’s ability to meet the critical need for broadband infrastructure.
An in-depth analysis of AT&T’s network shows the company has made fiber available to fewer than a third of households in its footprint, halting most residential deployment after mid-2019. The analysis also shows that 28% of households in AT&T’s footprint do not have access to service that meets the FCC’s standard for high-speed internet, and in rural counties 72% of households lack this access. In some places, AT&T is decommissioning its outdated DSL networks and leaving customers with no option but wireless service, which is not a substitute for wireline service.
In all, AT&T has made fiber-to-the-home available for fewer than one-third of the households in its network. AT&T’s employees — many of whom are Communications Workers of America (CWA) members — know that the company could be doing much more to connect its customers to high-speed Internet if it invested in upgrading its wireline network with fiber. They know the company’s recent job cuts — more than 40,000 since 2018 — are devastating communities and hobbling the company’s ability to meet the critical need for broadband infrastructure.
CWA recommends that AT&T dedicate a substantial share of its free cash flow to investment in next-generation networks across rural and urban communities, make its low-income product offerings available widely, and stop laying off its skilled, unionized workers and outsourcing work to low-wage, irresponsible subcontractors.
Editor’s Note:
According to CWA, AT&T has deployed fiber-to-the-home (FTTH) to only 28% of the households in its fiber coverage area as of the end of June 30, 2019.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..
The CWA/NDIA report said AT&T has targeted more affluent, non-rural areas for its fiber upgrades. Houses with fiber have a median income that’s 34% higher than those with DSL only. Across the rural counties in AT&T’s 21-state footprint, only a miniscule 5% have access to fiber, according to the report.
According to the report, 14.93 million—out of almost 53 million households—have access to AT&T’s fiber service. Among states, AT&T’s FTTH build out is the lowest in Michigan with 14% have access followed by Mississippi (15%) and Arkansas (16%).
“AT&T is also failing to make fiber available to the majority of its customer base in cities,” according to the report. “While most of AT&T’s fiber build has focused on urban areas—96 percent of households with access to fiber in AT&T’s footprint are in predominantly urban counties—the company hasn’t built enough fiber to reach the majority of urban residents. Seventy percent of households in urban counties still lack access to fiber from AT&T because the company has made fiber available to only 14.7 million households out of 48.4 million total households in these counties.”
The report also said there were many areas in AT&T’s footprint where it doesn’t offer the Federal Communications Commission’s “broadband” definition of 25 Mbps downstream and 3 Mbps upstream.
“For 28% of the households in its network footprint, AT&T’s internet service does not meet the FCC’s 25/3 Mbps benchmark to be considered broadband,” the report said. A key recommendation is that “AT&T must upgrade its network in rural communities to meet the FCC’s broadband definition, at least, and renew its efforts to deploy next-generation fiber.”
The report noted that in some areas where AT&T doesn’t provide faster speeds, cable operators, such as Comcast and Charter do.
“Even where that access is available from another provider—typically a cable provider—consumers are deprived of the benefits of competition in price, choice and service quality,” the report said.
…………………………………………………………………………………………………………
AT&T is counting on fiber for both residential and commercial services, including AT&T TV. In order to win over customers from cable operators, AT&T has paired its 1-Gig service with AT&T TV.
Regarding DSL, the report states: “AT&T’s poor maintenance of its DSL networks, with limited capacity for new connections, results in would-be new customers in some areas being denied service entirely or told they can only subscribe to fixed wireless service (a 4G wireless connection for home use, designed for rural areas).”
As expected, AT&T refuted the claims made in the CWA/NDIA report in a statement to FierceTelecom and Broadband World News on Monday afternoon.
“Our investment decisions are based on the capacity needs of our network and demand for our services. We do not ‘redline’ internet access and any suggestion that we do is wrong. We have invested more in the United States over the past 5 years (2015-2019) than any other public company. We have spent more than $125 billion in our U.S. wireless and wireline networks, including capital investments and acquisition of wireless spectrum and operations. Our 5G network provides high-speed internet access nationwide, our fiber network serves more 18 million customer locations and we continue to invest to expand both networks.”
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..
New Fiber Optics Market Report:
Finally, a new report by Technavio forecasts that the global fiber optics market size will grow by USD 2.44 billion during 2020-2024, progressing at a CAGR of almost 5% throughout the forecast period.

Image Credit: Technavio
The increase in the number of FTTH homes and subscribers is the key factor driving the market growth. A higher number of customers are opting for fiber optic connections to leverage broadband services. This reduces the requirements for customer premises equipment (CPE) and distribution point unit (DPU).
References:
https://cwa-union.org/sites/default/files/20201005attdigitalredlining.pdf
https://www.fiercetelecom.com/telecom/cwa-calls-out-at-t-s-lack-fiber-its-dsl-footprint
http://www.broadbandworldnews.com/document.asp?doc_id=764417
AT&T CEO: Fiber, Stories and (Video) Content to drive future revenues and growth
https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20201005005444/en/
Point Topic: China leads FTTH adoption with 80% of net adds through 1Q-2018
|
|
|
Point Topic: 931.6M Fixed Broadband Connections at end of Q4-2017; VDSL Growth but Copper Connections Continue Decline
|
|
|
PointTopic: Fiber & cable make up 3/4 of global fixed broadband subscriptions
Fiber and cable networks are dominating the global broadband market, with the technologies now servicing 77% of fixed subscriptions, new figures from Point Topic have revealed.
According to the Global Broadband Statistics, which take into account subscriptions up to the end of 2017, more than 50% of people in more than 40 countries, including Singapore (97%), China (89%), United States (87%), and the UK (55%), are connected via full-fiber, fiber-fed copper or cable.
Point Topic Research Director Dr Jolanta Stanke told the Broadband Forum:
“We are finding that customers across most global regions increasingly prefer faster broadband services delivered over fiber and cable platforms, as opposed to ADSL. This trend will continue as more bandwidth-hungry young consumers become paying decision makers, even though superfast 4G LTE and 5G mobile broadband services will compete for their wallets.”
Fiber-fed subscriptions – including Fiber-to-the-Home (FTTH), Fiber-to-the-Building (FTTB), Fiber-to-the-Cabinet (FTTC), Very High Bitrate Digital Subscriber Line (VDSL), VDSL2 and G.fast – accounted for 57% of broadband subscriptions, with more than 530 million connections. Stanke agreed VDSL and Gfast were together largely responsible for the growth that fiber has seen, with more than 30 operators across all continents deploying or trialing G.fast.
“G.fast gives operators a more cost-effective variant of fiber that will be used by operators who want to upgrade their existing networks quicker and more easily,” she added. “This could enable them to serve more customers in less densely populated areas, where direct fiber investment is less economically feasible.”
In total, cable, including hybrid fiber-coaxial, accounted for 20% of all fixed broadband connections. According to the report, the latest standard of this technology is currently deployed across several markets, being especially popular in North America, and can deliver gigabit download speeds.
Broadband Forum CEO Robin Mersh said the figures reflect the fact that new technologies that let operators deploy fiber deep into the network without having to enter buildings themselves are quickly moving from trials to mass deployment.
“If operators want to deliver competitive broadband services, maximizing their investments through the use of technologies like G.fast is vital,” said Mersh. “Expanding the footprint of their existing fiber networks in this way is cost-effective and delivers the gigabit speeds consumers crave. The growing trend towards fiber, whether its fiber-fed copper or full fiber, and cable deployments highlighted by Point Topic’s report confirms that the Forum’s work on interoperability and management of ‘fiber-extending’ technologies is vitally important.”
The voracious demand for connectivity is evident in the increased demand for fiber, cable and coax despite the parallel growth of LTE and MAYBE (?) “5G.”
Though “5G” is in currently proprietary to each wireless network operator, huge investments in fiber, coax and copper are being made because strategic planners expect 5G to be mainstream in the next several years (we think NOT until late 2021 at the earliest when IMT 2020 recommendations are finalized and implemented in base stations and endpoint devices.
Last month, Broadbandtrends’ Global Service Provider G.fast Deployment Strategies surveyed 33 incumbent and competitive broadband operators from across the globe. The market research firm found that four in five service providers have G.fast plans for this year and that 27% are in active deployments. AT&T is a huge supporter of G.fast while Verizon is not.
About the Broadband Forum
Broadband Forum, a non-profit industry organization, is focused on engineering smarter and faster broadband networks. The Forum’s flagship TR-069 CPE WAN Management Protocol has now exceeded 800 million installations worldwide.











